A Handbook of Statistical Analyses Using R — 2nd Edition
Chapter 12 Analysing Longitudinal Data I: Computerised Delivery of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy – Beat the Blues
12.1 Introduction
12.2 Analysing Longitudinal Data
12.3 Analysis Using R
R> data("BtheB", package = "HSAUR2")
R> layout(matrix(1:2, nrow = 1))
R> ylim <- range(BtheB[,grep("bdi", names(BtheB))],
+ na.rm = TRUE)
R> tau <- subset(BtheB, treatment == "TAU")[,
+ grep("bdi", names(BtheB))]
R> boxplot(tau, main = "Treated as Usual", ylab = "BDI",
+ xlab = "Time (in months)", names = c(0, 2, 3, 5, 8),
+ ylim = ylim)
R> btheb <- subset(BtheB, treatment == "BtheB")[,
+ grep("bdi", names(BtheB))]
R> boxplot(btheb, main = "Beat the Blues", ylab = "BDI",
+ xlab = "Time (in months)", names = c(0, 2, 3, 5, 8),
+ ylim = ylim)
We shall fit both random intercept and random intercept and slope models to the data including the baseline BDI values (pre.bdi), treatment group, drug and length as fixed effect covariates. Linear mixed effects models are fitted in R by using the lmer function contained in the lme4 package (Bates and Sarkar, 2012, Pinheiro and Bates, 2000, Bates, 2005), but an essential first step is to rearrange the data from the ‘wide form’ in which they appear in the BtheB data frame into the ‘long form’ in which each separate repeated measurement and associated covariate values appear as a separate row in a data.frame. This rearrangement can be made using the following code:
R> data("BtheB", package = "HSAUR2")R> BtheB$subject <- factor(rownames(BtheB))R> nobs <- nrow(BtheB)R> BtheB_long <- reshape(BtheB, idvar = "subject",+ varying = c("bdi.2m", "bdi.3m", "bdi.5m", "bdi.8m"),+ direction = "long")R> BtheB_long$time <- rep(c(2, 3, 5, 8), rep(nobs, 4))such that the data are now in the form (here shown for the first three subjects)
R> subset(BtheB_long, subject %in% c("1", "2", "3"))
drug length treatment bdi.pre subject time bdi1.2m No >6m TAU 29 1 2 22.2m Yes >6m BtheB 32 2 2 163.2m Yes <6m TAU 25 3 2 201.3m No >6m TAU 29 1 3 22.3m Yes >6m BtheB 32 2 3 243.3m Yes <6m TAU 25 3 3 NA1.5m No >6m TAU 29 1 5 NA2.5m Yes >6m BtheB 32 2 5 173.5m Yes <6m TAU 25 3 5 NA1.8m No >6m TAU 29 1 8 NA2.8m Yes >6m BtheB 32 2 8 203.8m Yes <6m TAU 25 3 8 NAThe resulting data.frame BtheB_long contains a number of missing values and in applying the lmer function these will be dropped. But notice it is only the missing values that are removed, not participants that have at least one missing value. All the available data is used in the model fitting process. The lmer function is used in a similar way to the lm function met in Chapter 6 with the addition of a random term to identify the source of the repeated measurements, here subject. We can fit the two models () and () and test which is most appropriate using
R> library("lme4")R> BtheB_lmer1 <- lmer(bdi ~ bdi.pre + time + treatment + drug ++ length + (1 | subject), data = BtheB_long,+ REML = FALSE, na.action = na.omit)R> BtheB_lmer2 <- lmer(bdi ~ bdi.pre + time + treatment + drug ++ length + (time | subject), data = BtheB_long,+ REML = FALSE, na.action = na.omit)R> anova(BtheB_lmer1, BtheB_lmer2)
Data: BtheB_longModels:BtheB_lmer1: bdi ~ bdi.pre + time + treatment + drug + length + (1 | subject)BtheB_lmer2: bdi ~ bdi.pre + time + treatment + drug + length + (time | subject) npar AIC BIC logLik -2*log(L) Chisq DfBtheB_lmer1 8 1887.5 1916.6 -935.75 1871.5BtheB_lmer2 10 1891.0 1927.4 -935.52 1871.0 0.4542 2 Pr(>Chisq)BtheB_lmer1BtheB_lmer2 0.7969
R> summary(BtheB_lmer1)
Linear mixed model fit by maximum likelihood ['lmerMod']Formula:bdi ~ bdi.pre + time + treatment + drug + length + (1 | subject) Data: BtheB_long AIC BIC logLik -2*log(L) df.resid 1887.5 1916.6 -935.7 1871.5 272Scaled residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max-2.6975 -0.5026 -0.0638 0.4124 3.8203Random effects: Groups Name Variance Std.Dev. subject (Intercept) 48.78 6.984 Residual 25.14 5.014Number of obs: 280, groups: subject, 97Fixed effects: Estimate Std. Error t value(Intercept) 5.59239 2.24244 2.494bdi.pre 0.63968 0.07789 8.212time -0.70476 0.14639 -4.814treatmentBtheB -2.32908 1.67036 -1.394drugYes -2.82495 1.72684 -1.636length>6m 0.19708 1.63832 0.120Correlation of Fixed Effects: (Intr) bdi.pr time trtmBB drugYsbdi.pre -0.682time -0.238 0.020tretmntBthB -0.390 0.121 0.018drugYes -0.073 -0.237 -0.022 -0.323length>6m -0.243 -0.242 -0.036 0.002 0.157
The summary method for lmer objects doesn’t print -values for Gaussian mixed models because the degrees of freedom of the reference distribution are not obvious. However, one can rely on the asymptotic normal distribution for computing univariate -values for the fixed effects using the cftest function from package multcomp. The asymptotic -values are given in Figure 12.3.
R> cftest(BtheB_lmer1)
Simultaneous Tests for General Linear HypothesesFit: lmer(formula = bdi ~ bdi.pre + time + treatment + drug + length + (1 | subject), data = BtheB_long, REML = FALSE, na.action = na.omit)Linear Hypotheses: Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(>|z|)(Intercept) == 0 5.59239 2.24244 2.494 0.0126bdi.pre == 0 0.63968 0.07789 8.212 2.22e-16time == 0 -0.70476 0.14639 -4.814 1.48e-06treatmentBtheB == 0 -2.32908 1.67036 -1.394 0.1632drugYes == 0 -2.82495 1.72684 -1.636 0.1019length>6m == 0 0.19708 1.63832 0.120 0.9043(Univariate p values reported)
We can check the assumptions of the final model fitted to the BtheB data, i.e., the normality of the random effect terms and the residuals, by first using the ranef method to predict the former and the residuals method to calculate the differences between the observed data values and the fitted values, and then using normal probability plots on each. How the random effects are predicted is explained briefly in Section . The necessary R code to obtain the effects, residuals and plots is shown with Figure 12.4. There appear to be no large departures from linearity in either plot.
R> layout(matrix(1:2, ncol = 2))
R> qint <- ranef(BtheB_lmer1)$subject[["(Intercept)"]]
R> qres <- residuals(BtheB_lmer1)
R> qqnorm(qint, ylab = "Estimated random intercepts",
+ xlim = c(-3, 3), ylim = c(-20, 20),
+ main = "Random intercepts")
R> qqline(qint)
R> qqnorm(qres, xlim = c(-3, 3), ylim = c(-20, 20),
+ ylab = "Estimated residuals",
+ main = "Residuals")
R> qqline(qres)
R> bdi <- BtheB[, grep("bdi", names(BtheB))]
R> plot(1:4, rep(-0.5, 4), type = "n", axes = FALSE,
+ ylim = c(0, 50), xlab = "Months", ylab = "BDI")
R> axis(1, at = 1:4, labels = c(0, 2, 3, 5))
R> axis(2)
R> for (i in 1:4) {
+ dropout <- is.na(bdi[,i + 1])
+ points(rep(i, nrow(bdi)) + ifelse(dropout, 0.05, -0.05),
+ jitter(bdi[,i]), pch = ifelse(dropout, 20, 1))
+ }
References
- lme4: linear mixed-effects models using s4 classes. Note: R package version 0.999375-42 External Links: Link Cited by: §12.3.
- Fitting linear mixed models in R. R News 5 (1), pp. 27–30. External Links: Link Cited by: §12.3.
- Mixed-effects models in S and S-PLUS. Springer-Verlag, New York, USA. Cited by: §12.3.